Replacement is the appointment where the repair-or-replace question stops being abstract. It is usually reached one of three ways: the tank has failed, the unit has failed repeatedly, or the heater is old enough that its next failure is a matter of when.
The three questions that decide it
Where is the failure? A part can be swapped. A tank shell cannot. Water from the base or seam of the tank is the clearest replacement signal there is.
How many failures is this? One failed thermocouple on a sound tank is a repair. A third call in a year on a fifteen-year-old unit is a pattern, and parts start costing more than they return.
Does the same unit still fit? Like-for-like replacement keeps the venting, the power and the connections unchanged. Changing type — tank to tankless — changes all three, and that is an installation job with more to it.
What replacement involves
The old unit is isolated, drained and removed. The new one is set, connected, strapped and tested. Removal of the old heater and getting it out of the house is part of the work, which is worth knowing before you price it out yourself.
Tank or tankless
Tankless suits households that want endless hot water and can accept a different venting and power arrangement. A tank is simpler, tolerates low flow better, and stores hot water for several draws at once. Neither is universally better — the fit with the house and the household's peak use is what decides.
What is not published
No price, no timeframe and no financing terms appear on this page, because the business has not supplied them as standing facts. What a replacement costs depends on the unit, the venting and the space, and that is worked out from the job. The questions that come before this appointment are the ones in repair or replace.