Water Heater Leaking From the Bottom: What It Means Before You Call
Water at the base of a water heater can come from a fitting, a valve or the tank itself — and only one of those is repairable.
A puddle under a water heater is alarming, but "leaking from the bottom" covers several different faults. Where the water starts decides whether this is a plumbing repair or a new heater.
The four possibilities
The tank seam or shell. Water appears at the very bottom edge of the tank, often beaded rather than running. This is the shell failing, and it cannot be repaired. It also does not get better: the leak grows.
A fitting or connection. Water tracks down from a threaded joint or a supply connection and collects at the base, which makes it look like the tank. Corrosion at the joint, a failed nipple or a loose union is repairable.
The relief valve or its discharge. The valve opens when pressure or temperature runs high. If the discharge pipe ends near the base, the puddle looks like a tank leak. The valve needs replacing, and the reason it opened — pressure, a failed expansion tank, a thermostat — needs checking.
Condensation or a nearby leak. Cold-water condensation on the tank, or water from a pipe above, can accumulate in the pan.
What to do now
Shut off the water supply to the heater. Switch off power or gas to the unit if the controls are reachable and it is safe to do so. Move anything the water can reach — a leak beside flooring, framing or an electrical panel is a property problem within hours.
How the distinction gets made
By looking: trace the water upward, check the fittings above the tank, and look at whether the seam itself is wet. That is a two-minute inspection on site and it is the difference between a valve and a replacement.
The honest summary
Fittings, valves and pipes are repairs. The tank is not. If the unit is old and the shell has gone, the next question is not how to seal it but what replaces it. Leak repair covers the fitting-and-valve side, water heater replacement covers the shell, and the questions that settle that call are set out in repair or replace.